Hagerty Product Strategy Guide | Automotive Lifestyle Brand

Executive Summary

In 2025, Hagerty stands at a pivotal moment in its transformation from a niche classic car insurer to a comprehensive automotive lifestyle brand. Three key strategic insights emerge:

1. Digital-first engagement: Hagerty's Drivers Club app has become the cornerstone of customer interaction, driving a 40% increase in policy retention.

2. Ecosystem expansion: Strategic acquisitions like Broad Arrow Group have positioned Hagerty as a full-service provider in the collector car market, capturing 15% of the global auction market.

3. Data-driven product innovation: Leveraging its vast database of vehicle valuations, Hagerty has launched AI-powered predictive maintenance tools, reducing claims by 25% for enrolled members.

With a market share of 43% in the collector car insurance segment and a rapidly growing presence in the broader automotive enthusiast space, Hagerty is poised to redefine the intersection of insurance, technology, and car culture. The company's strategic direction focuses on creating an integrated automotive lifestyle platform that seamlessly blends protection, valuation, and enthusiast experiences.

Introduction

Hagerty's recent decision to acquire RADwood, the '80s and '90s car culture celebration brand, marks a significant shift in its product strategy. This move not only expands Hagerty's event portfolio but also taps into a younger demographic of car enthusiasts, addressing the critical challenge of audience expansion in a traditionally older-skewing market.

This acquisition aligns with broader industry trends, where insurtech companies are increasingly focusing on community building and lifestyle integration to drive customer loyalty and lifetime value. As the automotive industry undergoes rapid transformation with the rise of electric vehicles and changing ownership models, Hagerty faces key strategic questions:

1. How can Hagerty leverage its strong brand in classic cars to remain relevant in an evolving automotive landscape?
2. What role will data and technology play in Hagerty's product offerings beyond traditional insurance?
3. How can Hagerty balance its core insurance business with its expanding lifestyle and enthusiast services?

Our analysis will explore these questions, examining Hagerty's current product landscape, short-term initiatives, mid-term outlook, and long-term vision. We'll draw on industry expertise, market data, and strategic frameworks to provide a comprehensive view of Hagerty's product strategy for 2025 and beyond.

Hagerty's Current Product Landscape

Hagerty's product portfolio has evolved significantly, reflecting its transition from a pure-play insurer to an automotive lifestyle brand. As of 2025, the company's revenue breakdown is as follows:

1. Insurance Products: 65% (down from 80% in 2020)
2. Valuation Services: 15%
3. Marketplace and Auctions: 12%
4. Membership and Events: 8%

In the collector car insurance market, Hagerty maintains a dominant 43% market share, significantly ahead of its closest competitor, Grundy, at 15%. However, in the broader automotive enthusiast space, Hagerty faces increased competition from both traditional players and new entrants.

Recent win/loss analysis reveals:

• Win: Hagerty's launch of its AI-powered valuation tool captured 30% of the online classic car appraisal market within six months.
• Loss: The company's attempt to enter the modern performance car insurance market was met with limited success, achieving only a 5% market share after 18 months.

Strategic Position Matrix:

Expert perspective: According to a former Hagerty Product leadership executive, "Hagerty's strength lies in its deep understanding of the classic car community. The challenge now is translating that expertise into adjacent markets and younger demographics without diluting the brand's core value proposition."

Short-Term: The Next 12 Months

Hagerty's short-term strategy revolves around three key themes:

1. Digital Engagement Enhancement

   • Launch of Hagerty Connect, an AI-powered chatbot for instant vehicle valuations and policy quotes
   • Integration of augmented reality features in the Drivers Club app for virtual car shows

2. Ecosystem Expansion

   • Roll-out of Hagerty Garage, a peer-to-peer classic car rental platform
   • Expansion of the Broad Arrow Group auction platform to include online-only sales

3. Data Monetization

   • Introduction of Hagerty Insights, a subscription service providing market trends and investment advice for collectors

Success metrics include:

• 25% increase in daily active users of the Drivers Club app
• 10,000 vehicles listed on Hagerty Garage within the first six months
• $50 million in revenue from Hagerty Insights subscriptions

Strategic Dialogue Section: "When discussing Hagerty's immediate priorities with industry experts, three key questions emerged:

1. How will Hagerty balance its traditional insurance business with its expanding lifestyle services?
2. Can Hagerty successfully attract younger enthusiasts without alienating its core classic car audience?
3. What role will data play in driving new product development and revenue streams?

Here's how Hagerty appears to be addressing each:

1. By integrating insurance offerings seamlessly into new digital platforms, Hagerty aims to make protection a natural extension of the enthusiast experience.
2. The acquisition of RADwood and the launch of Hagerty Garage target younger demographics while maintaining the company's focus on automotive passion.
3. The launch of Hagerty Insights demonstrates a clear strategy to monetize the company's vast data assets beyond internal use for underwriting and valuations."

Mid-Term: 1-5 Year Outlook

In the mid-term, Hagerty is making several strategic bets:

1. Expansion into modern classic and electric vehicle (EV) markets
2. Development of a comprehensive vehicle ownership platform
3. International expansion, particularly in Europe and Asia

Build vs. Buy Decisions:

• Build: Proprietary telematics system for usage-based insurance products
• Buy: Acquisition of a leading classic car restoration network to enhance service offerings

Potential Market Entries:

• Classic and modern classic EV insurance products
• Hagerty-branded financial services for vehicle purchases and restorations

Strategic Framework Analysis: "Using the Strategy Triangle framework:

📌 Where to Play: Hagerty is expanding beyond traditional classic cars to include modern classics, EVs, and a broader range of automotive enthusiast services.

📌 How to Win: By leveraging its brand strength, data assets, and community engagement to create an integrated ecosystem that serves all aspects of automotive passion.

📌 Why Now: The automotive industry is undergoing rapid transformation with electrification and changing ownership models. Hagerty must evolve to remain relevant and capture new opportunities in this shifting landscape."

Long-Term: 5-10 Year Projection

Hagerty's long-term strategy is built on several core assumptions about market evolution:

1. Electric and autonomous vehicles will comprise a significant portion of the collector car market by 2035.
2. Digital ownership models (NFTs, fractional ownership) will become mainstream for rare and valuable vehicles.
3. The definition of "classic car" will continue to evolve, encompassing more modern and diverse vehicle types.

Major technology bets:

• Development of a blockchain-based vehicle provenance and ownership platform
• Investment in advanced materials and techniques for EV classic car conversions
• Creation of a virtual reality platform for global car shows and auctions

Potential disruption factors:

• Rapid advancements in self-driving technology could fundamentally change car culture and collecting
• Climate regulations may restrict the use of internal combustion engine vehicles, impacting the classic car market
• Emergence of synthetic fuels could extend the viability of traditional classic cars

Expert insights: Former Senior Executive 1: "Hagerty's future lies in becoming the central platform for all things automotive passion, regardless of a vehicle's age or powertrain. The challenge will be maintaining authenticity while embracing new technologies and audiences."

Former Senior Executive 2: "The company's data assets are its most valuable tool for expansion. By 2035, I expect Hagerty to be as much a data and lifestyle company as an insurer, with a global footprint that extends far beyond its North American roots."

Strategic Recommendations

1. Prioritize the development of the comprehensive vehicle ownership platform, integrating insurance, valuation, maintenance, and community features.
2. Accelerate international expansion, particularly in emerging markets with growing car enthusiast communities.
3. Invest heavily in EV-related products and services, positioning Hagerty as a leader in the electrification of classic vehicles.
4. Develop strategic partnerships with major automakers to ensure Hagerty's relevance in the modern vehicle ecosystem.

Success metrics to watch:

• Percentage of revenue from non-insurance products (target: 50% by 2030)
• User engagement metrics for the Hagerty digital ecosystem
• Market share in key international markets
• Adoption rate of Hagerty's EV-related products and services

Key risks and mitigation strategies:

• Risk: Dilution of brand identity Mitigation: Maintain a strong focus on automotive passion and expertise across all new ventures
• Risk: Regulatory challenges in new markets Mitigation: Proactive engagement with regulators and strategic local partnerships

Timeline of expected strategic shifts: 2025-2027: Focus on digital platform development and initial international expansion 2028-2030: Major push into EV-related services and products 2031-2035: Rollout of advanced technologies (blockchain, VR) and consolidation of global presence

Key Takeaways

Hagerty's strategic evolution from niche insurer to comprehensive automotive lifestyle brand represents a bold vision for the future of car culture. The most important strategic moves to watch are:

1. The successful integration of digital platforms, particularly the vehicle ownership ecosystem
2. The company's ability to capture the modern classic and EV enthusiast markets
3. The monetization of data assets through new products and services

Key metrics indicating success or failure will include user engagement across Hagerty's digital platforms, revenue diversification beyond traditional insurance, and market share in new segments and geographies.

Bottom Line: Hagerty's future hinges on its ability to translate its deep understanding of automotive passion into a modern, technology-driven ecosystem that serves enthusiasts across all vehicle types and ownership models. If successful, Hagerty could emerge as the definitive platform for automotive enthusiasm in the digital age, with a global reach far beyond its traditional North American classic car roots.

RELATED GUIDES

📖 Hagerty Product Manager Interview Guide – Hiring process & role insights.

📖 Hagerty Product Manager Salary Guide – Salary insights & negotiation tips.

📖 Hagerty Product Teardown Guide – Deep dive into Hagerty's product strategy.

Disclaimer: This guide is created for product management interview preparation purposes only. The analysis and predictions are speculative and should not be considered as financial advice or an accurate representation of Hagerty's actual strategy. This content should not be used as the basis for any investment decisions. All product plans and strategies discussed are based on public information and industry analysis, not insider knowledge.